|
Urban Policy Analysis (Revised) (Public Policy 248/348; Sociology 256/329; Political Science 256) Terry Nichols Clark tnclark@midway.uchicago.edu University of Chicago Chicago, Illinois, USA Fall 2000 NOTE: Professor Clark has an earlier version of this course in the Syllabus Archive dated 1995. This syllabus has been substantially revised for use in Fall 2000 classes. Teaching Assistant was Anne Bartlett at albartle@midway.uchicago.edu. |
SYLLABUSHow does urban policy get made? Do leaders matter? Some see specific leaders, and their preferences, as key. If leaders matter, then are business, political, or other kinds of leaders more important--and where, when, and why? A second view is that capitalism, or more recently, global markets, make specific leaders irrelevant. A third view is that leaders like mayors are growing weaker if not irrelevant since citizens, interest groups, and media have grown so powerful. We examine theoretical statements of these views, comparative studies, and case studies of specifics. But there is not a simple answer: some evidence supports each of the three views. Thus, as the course proceeds we will give you some tools to sift through and interpret such conflicting evidence, as you will no doubt confront similar conflicts in the future.The course introduces you to core urban issues, whether your goal is to conduct research, interpret reports by others, make policy decisions, or watch the tube and then be able to discuss these issues as a more informed citizen. One former student suggested that we announce that each class will show you how at least one conception from the N.Y. Times or CNN is wrong, and how you can reach a more informed interpretation. He also suggested you could get your money back if we don’t, but the University’s legal counsel advised against this. The course presents an overview of urban policy analysis, focusing on leadership patterns of public officials and their implications for urban public policy, especially economic development. In the process we review the major interpretations about how urban politics and leadership work in cities around the world today. What strategies encourage or discourage development? Which specific cities and leaders have followed different sets of strategies and with what consequences? What shifts in urban political cultures have accompanied different sets of policies? Case studies of individual cities and comparative analyses across cities around the world will be used. Examples are drawn especially from Chicago, the most studied city in the world, because it used to illustrate such dramatic examples of poverty, crime, gangs, violence, political corruption, and more. But it has recently become the Leisure City on the Lakefront, where airports and school parking lots are converted into parks, and Navy Pier, the Bulls, great restaurants, music, and theater draw more visitors than the Grand Canyon. What has happened here and why? How much does this transformation follow a pattern also around the world? To answer, we draw on work from the Fiscal Austerity and Urban Innovation (FAUI) Project, a study of more than 7,000 cities in 34 countries, that began in 1983, and has generated many counter-intuitive results from North America, Asia, Europe, and Latin America. Data from Chicago and the international FAUI project are available for student projects and papers. We also maintain contacts with many organizations in Chicago and can help arrange an internship as part of a student project if you are interested. This is a lecture/discussion course. It feeds into an optional research project as is detailed in the first few course sessions. Many students revise and continue working on papers in the Winter, and some develop these into BA or MA papers. The Winter Workshop in Urban Policy is offered to provide continuity for such projects. READINGSNOTE: Readings are labeled with one, two or three stars to indicate their importance for the course. Three star readings are terrific meals. Recommended but less important readings are labeled Extra.I. LEADERSHIP AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT: PERSPECTIVESA. Regimes/Leadership
EXAM AND PAPER ALTERNATIVES FOR THE COURSETo provide more flexibility to students, four alternatives are open. You can:
If mom requires a B average, and you worried, give us a note, and we can give you a B or better or instead an R or P, after we grade all exams. Keep mom happy! You can always do a memo or two, or a short paper during or after the quarter that will only improve your grade, the amount depending no how much work you do. More products from you will only be evaluated n a way that ratchets up your grade, so when in doubt do more. Other grade options: A for audit or R for registration credit only (no requirements), or P for Pass, for which you must complete at least two exams or a paper, or all three. It is acceptable to give the instructors a note indicating that you would like us to record a letter grade, for instance, of B- or better, or a P if the letter grade would be below B-. Lecture/discussion sessions will be held Monday and Wednesday. Friday is a Review/Research and paper preparation session. The class discussion grade includes the Friday sessions. |
| % Weight for final grade -- class=10% in all options | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MT | FINAL | PAPER | CLASS | |
| Only Paper | 90 | 10 | ||
| Paper & Midterm | 35 | 55 | 10 | |
| Final & Paper | 30 | 60 | 10 | |
| Midterm & Final | 35 | 55 | 10 | |
| Paper, Midterm, & Final | 25 | 32.5 | 32.5 | 10 |
DATES FOR FALL 2000Midterm: Oct 25, Wednesday of Fifth Week. Covers first three parts of course.Paper draft proposal due: Oct 30 Paper outline (revised from draft proposal) due: November 1, Wednesday of Sixth week. Paper due Nov 27, Monday of Tenth Week. The Nov 27 class, Monday of Tenth Week, will be a question and answer session reviewing the whole course. The final exam: November 29, Wednesday of Tenth Week, covers all parts of the course. Please submit a copy of your paper that I can keep on file for future students. Past papers are available now in Regenstein. If they do not appear on a card for current course readings, they may be listed under Soc. 256/329 "inactive reserve" for past years. Note that the specific requirements for this year differ from past years, so previous papers do not necessarily include both case study and comparative work. Related student papers are also on file for Soc. 328 (Urban Structure and Decision-Making) and esp. Soc. 410-411 (Workshop in Urban Policy). Addendum: the Library is revising its holdings and seeking to make past papers available over the Internet; we will keep you informed as to progress. THE COURSE PAPERTwo Options are available. For both we suggest preparing a one page outline for reactions by the instructors before you undertake the bulk of the work on the paper.Option 1 - Broad Topic Possible. The paper should in some way build on the material in the course, but in Option 1 we are relatively broad and tolerant in topic selection. Papers may be as different as analyzing a single concept in depth (like urban amenities and how they impact development), contrasting two cities concerning how their leaderships operate, or assessing how the course readings help address a particular issue of concern to you, like urban development in Japan. You should choose some phenomenon, topic, or policy area that can be studied 1. in Chicago and 2. using some of the national (or occasionally international) urban data that we have available for use on individual PCs or the U of C minis or mainframe systems. For example, what is the role of the press in affecting urban development decisions? This can be studied through reviewing past work on Chicago (esp. books on this reading list) to form your own analytical perspective and to see what they say about the press, reading some newspapers to see what evidence they may provide about their role in some decisions, interviews with some thoughtful informants, plus any other creative method you can think of. Then you can analyze the impact of the press on economic development decisions using one or more of the comparative urban data sets we have available as SPSS.SYS files, including:
Past student papers that used the FAUI, GSS and World Values Surveys are published in Terry Nichols Clark and Michael Rempel, eds., Citizen Politics and Post-Industrial Societies. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1996, esp. By Umeori on Japan, Mayer on Illinois, Rempel on the GSS, and Butts on Feminism in 14 countries. You can work individually or with other students on either the Chicago portion or the national/international analysis, in conducting your fieldwork and data analysis, as well as in writing the paper. But if you write together, be very explicit about the role of each in the overall project. It is probably easier for this reason to work together closely if you so choose, but to write separate course papers. The Friday sessions will be devoted to more detailed consideration of research for the paper, and if there is enough interest, include sessions on basics with computers, including Excel and SPSS. No prior knowledge of computers or these programs is required as a course prerequisite, but if you have no experience to date, working with other students who have more experience should help. For students interested in pursuing a paper for more than one quarter (such as a BA or MA paper), the Workshop in Urban Policy will be offered next quarter, Winter 1993, exclusively to assist students in completing research papers. More specifics about the paper apply to students registering for the Research Project in Sociology and Public Policy.v In past years, some students have chosen to prepare a major paper (BA, MA, etc.) starting with the this course. To facilitate such work, if you like you may register for both Urban Policy Analysis and a Reading and Research course and/or the Research Project in Sociology and Public Policy, in the Fall or Winter Quarter. Short Paper/Memo: The normal paper is about 20 pages double spaced, but you may also submit a series of memos, commenting on readings or any topics related to the course, or a shorter paper (such as 10 pages), if you also take the exams. |