Diagnosing "The Intemperate": Medicine, Gender, and Early National Temperance Reform

Scott C. Martin
Bowling Green State University

[CLICK HERE FOR FULL PAPER]

Physicians' contributions to early nineteenth-century temperance reform have long been recognized but insufficiently scrutinized. Temperance advocates relied on physicians for scientific proof of the deleterious effects of alcohol on the human body and mind, which doctors happily provided. As they did so, they inevitably confronted questions about gender: did alcohol effect men and women differently? Physicians' attempts to answer these questions reflected both the current state of scientific and medical knowledge, and their own culturally-mediated notions about male and female qualities.

This paper focuses on the interplay between medical opinion and popular ideas about gender and temperance in the work of Charles D. Meigs, a Philadelphia physician and pioneer of American gynecology. Based on research into medical writing and popular culture, it demonstrates how Meigs used popular images of women suffering from male intemperance -- notably, Lydia Sigourneyís story, "The Intemperate," to illustrate the "Natural" qualities of the female character: fidelity, obedience, and perseverance. Meigs' work as a doctor and temperance reformer illustrates the reciprocal relationship between medical science and popular culture during the early national. period, and sheds light on the evolution of nineteenth-century gender ideology.