This evening, in the faculty of education university computer lab where I
teach, I gave a special demonstration for a number of media folks from an
educational television network. As I left I saw that a surveillance camera
had been installed in the lab overnight. This was done without my knowledge
and without any consultation. I have no idea who is behind the decision to
install the surveillance camera but I expect the dean had to give his
approval for it installation. I have had previous conversations with him
about this and he knows clearly my thoughts about these issues.
THE ISSUES
1. The surveillance cameras represent a violation of my academic freedom.
None of colleagues is required to teach under these conditions.
2. The conditions of my contract have been altered without any input,
consultation or due process. Our faculty is normally governed by democratic
procedures.
3. I feel a strong sense of responsibility with respect to the social
consequences of our use of technology to support and nurture human growth
and development. The installation of a surveillance camera violates the
sense of trust that I want to convey to my students and sends a negative
message which is unwarranted and undeserved. It's very presence establishes
a tone of mistrust. The learning conditions in my lab have been altered --
in the negative.
4. Yet another issue relates to the concept of technological determinism:
whether we use technology for constructive and positive purposes or whether
we ignore those consequences and simply use technology for whatever purpose
we want simply because we have the capacity to do so -- regardless of the
human consequences or long term effects.
5. We have choices about how we spend our money -- whether we put it into
human or technological resources. I would rather support more student lab
assistants than put dollars into technology.
6. There have been NO incidents of theft or even the slightest vandalism
this year in the lab that might provide an argument to support the
installation of the surveillance camera.
MY PLAN
My plan is to refuse to teach in the lab until the camera is removed. I
will not refuse to teach. I will simply refuse to teach in the lab and will
move my students to another classroom. Fortunately, next week is the last
week of winter classes. If an amicable resolution cannot be found I plan to
file a grievance with my faculty union.
MY REQUEST
I would like to request your feedback -- your support -- and other
perspectives that might strengthen my argument.
Please write to me privately.
Many thanks.
Bobbi A. Kerlin
bakerlin@flash.lakeheadu.ca
****EDTECH Editor's Note: As many others may be interested in this
topic, please also include EDTECH in any responses of general interest.
Thanks/VB****