Call for papers: Sketched by themselves.
Society tested by “panoramic” literature
Call for Papers Date:
Special issue of the open acces journal Interférences littéraires - Literaire interferenties
Nathalie Preiss (Université de Reims) & Valérie Stiénon (F.N.R.S - Université de Liège )
In the first half of the 19th century, numerous books were published throughout Eu-rope that combined the satirical depiction of manners with the form of the self-portrait. These books, usually organised in edited collections, offered a textual and iconic representation of different “types” associated with social groups or professions: the doctor, the grisset, the urchin, the seamstress, the door-keeper, the reporter, the poet. Following Walter Benjamin, this litera¬ture has retrospectively been called “panoramique” [Benjamin 1989] after the panoramas and dioramas that offer a large vista to the public.
The development of this literature is characterised by the mutual influence of French, English, German, Austrian, Spanish and Belgian sketches, such as England and the English (Lon¬don, Bentley, 1833), Paris ou le Livre des Cent-et-un (Paris, Ladvocat, 1831-1834), Les Français peints par eux-mêmes (Paris, Curmer, 1842), La Grande Ville (Paris, Bureau Central des Publications nou¬velles, 1842-1843), Le Diable à Paris (Paris, Hetzel, 1845-1846), Les Belges peints par eux-mêmes (Bruxelles, Raabé, 1839), Berlin und die Berliner (Berlin, Klemann, 1840-1841), Wien und die Wiener (Pesth, Heckenast, 1844, serialised since 1841) and Los Españoles pintados por sí mismos (Madrid, Ignacio Boix, 1843). The French Physiologies [Preiss 1999], the Spanish costumbrismo [Montesinos 1960], the German and Austrian generational portrait 1980] and the English sketch [Sha 1998] are all sub-genres of this literature which engages with the cultural climate of the 19th century and brings it towards modernity, eager to establish its originality and specificity.
These sociographical sketches stage the modes and manners of a European society at the time of the emergence of romanticism and national identity. To that extent they often function as the focal point of reflections on nation and nationality. Since the period also witnessed the first large social and demographic surveys [Leclerc 1979], the birth of the human sciences and the accelerated development of journalism and the press, we find in these texts a nexus of poli¬tical and ideological interests. The collections of national “types” composed by self-portraits of a people in terms of national identity thus offer a fount of historical and sociological knowledge of the period.
In terms of the literary system, this period is also characterised by an increasing specia¬lisation of discourses and knowledge. The development of the natural sciences and the sub¬sequent appearance of the human and social sciences lead to a redefinition of literature and literary practices. In this context, panoramic literature seeks to define itself in relation to and in opposition with scientific models [Carlino & Wenger 2007]. A number of texts indeed borrow terms and cognitive models from the medical sciences (“Physiologies” in France ; “Anatomy” in Interférences littéraires/Literaire interferenties 2011 England, after the 1621 Anatomy of Melancholy which knew numerous editions between 1800 and 1830; or “Pathology” which was a common title for short monographic sketches).
This project aims to bring together and, hence, make more visible the research that is internationally conducted in this domain. For, despite some recent studies [Preiss 1999 ; Diaz 2004 ; Lauster 2007] and contemporary bibliographical overviews [Lacombe 1887], research into this panoramic literature remains scattered and largely unacknowledged. The sociology of literature may offer an important tool for investigating these texts’ embeddedness within soci¬ety. In addition, recent studies of the relation between literature and journalism [Chollet 1983 ; Thérenty & Vaillant 2005] or the relation between literature and science [e.g. the “épistémocri¬tique” of Pierssens 1990] may offer interesting frameworks for analysis.
Given the particular nature of the literature studied, we propose different methodologi¬cal approaches. A poetical and linguistic approach will enable a study of the various literary forms and genres that may constitute the self-portait: journalistic chronicle, micro-narrative, sketch, essay, “anatomy”, “pathology”, satire or parody, etc. An critical or epistemological ap¬proach may enable us to uncover the links between these texts and the emerging scientific dis¬courses such as ethnography, sociology, economics, anatomy and medical hygiene. A compara¬tive approach may trace the influences and transfers between the different European literatures in this respect, for instance by studying the mediating role of editorial practices and adaptations (e.g. as evident in the transfer from Français peints par eux-mêmes to Los Españoles pintados por sí mismos).
In order to realise this interdisciplinary aim and to avoid a juxtaposition of isolated case stu¬dies, we propose a transversal approach which studies not just the way the “other” is constituted as “other” in each national literature, but also highlights the way in which models and types circulate across national borders, effectively moving from one text to the next.
The journal Interférences littéraires – Literaire interferenties aims to study literary discourse from both a theoretical and a historical perspective with a focus on its interactions with other types of discourse and other paradigms of thought. The editorial board of the journal both reflects and warrants the plurilinguistic and transnational make-up of the journal in that it is made up of scho¬lars specialising in the different literatures.
Proposals of about 350 words may be sent to firstname.lastname@example.org ; V.Stienon@ulg.ac.be, email@example.com before the 20th of September 2011. Authors can expect a decision from the 20th of October. The deadline for the full articles is the 31st of January 2012.
Send comments and questions to H-Net
Webstaff. H-Net reproduces announcements that have been submitted to us as a
free service to the academic community. If you are interested in an announcement
listed here, please contact the organizers or patrons directly. Though we strive
to provide accurate information, H-Net cannot accept responsibility for the text of
announcements appearing in this service. (Administration)